8.8 + tire size

Captian Carnage
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 344
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 1:08 pm
Jeep Year: 2004
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler

8.8 + tire size

Unread post by Captian Carnage »

Would a 8.8 with alloys handle a 39.5 tires I was told a 44 in the rear with alloys would handle 37s maybe 38s
I would think the 8.8 will be about same with 39.5 as the 44 would be with 37s or 38s
User avatar
ChrisD
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 1791
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2009 12:53 pm
Jeep Year: 2003
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler
Real Name: Chris
Location: Westminster, Ma

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ChrisD »

Depends.... R u behind the wheel??
nostaw

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by nostaw »

I think you're pushing the 8.8 pretty far on a tire that big... I wouldn't expect it to last too long if you push it too hard.

JW
User avatar
ZAEDOCK
BSJ Member
Posts: 2428
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:18 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ZAEDOCK »

Captian Carnage wrote:Would a 8.8 with alloys handle a 39.5 tires I was told a 44 in the rear with alloys would handle 37s maybe 38s
I would think the 8.8 will be about same with 39.5 as the 44 would be with 37s or 38s

IMO, an 8.8 isn't that much stronger than a 44, and to be honest, has issues that make it weaker in some aspects. The tubes have been known to spin in the housing and the carrier caps flex under hard abuse. With alloy axle shafts, a Dana44 is just about equal to a 8.8. Perterson's 4 Wheel and Off Road magazine listed the Dana44 above a 8.8 for overall strength (the took into consideration the c-clip axle retention).

The 8.8 with 39.5's would definitely NOT be the same as a 44 on 37's or 38's.

There are MANY factors that need to be included. For example, my 38x15.5" Mickey Thompson Claws weigh 150 lbs each! That's 20-30 lbs MORE than a 39 or 39.5" IROK mounted on the same wheel.

IMO, Tire MASS has more to do with axle longevity than tire SIZE. When you get down to it, there isn't too much difference between a 38" and a 39" tire.


Now, my advice to you (knowing how you drive and where you drive), is to just get a Dana 60, Dana 70, or a 14 Bolt. A beefed Ford 9" would be durable too.
When push comes to shove, the 8.8 is still only a half ton axle.
Carl McFly wrote:X2, I agree with Joe. And not just because he's man candy
BSJ President 2003 - 2005
Captian Carnage
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 344
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 1:08 pm
Jeep Year: 2004
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by Captian Carnage »

Yea still a half ton axle My tubes are welded and alloys with c clip elimitator will help But Its still me driving I should be able to find a rear 60 or a 14 bolt in 6 months LOL It will be part of a Suspension over haul in December I know alot people with beater trucks that have 14 bolts I will start to look in May i will have 6 months from may to get all my parts together for my build It wont be a TJ any more LMAO
User avatar
ChrisD
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 1791
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2009 12:53 pm
Jeep Year: 2003
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler
Real Name: Chris
Location: Westminster, Ma

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ChrisD »

While we are on this subject... Wouldn't you kill the drive shaft/TC with that setup? Also, with the limited options in the area, would that not be considered overkill and more just for bragging about size? Myself, I am shooting to be that little guy that could! LOL
User avatar
ZAEDOCK
BSJ Member
Posts: 2428
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:18 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ZAEDOCK »

Chris wrote:While we are on this subject... Wouldn't you kill the drive shaft/TC with that setup?
Nah. I run Spicer 1310 u-joints in my driveshafts. Some use that u-joint as the "fuse" in your driveline.

Chris wrote:Also, with the limited options in the area, would that not be considered overkill and more just for bragging about size? Myself, I am shooting to be that little guy that could! LOL
There are plenty of places to go. You're welcome to ride shotgun at the NE4W BBQ this summer. :twisted:

The area (no trail names) that the NEA Fall Crawl takes place and where Baystate sometimes runs, has trails that you can barely walk on. The trails that Baystate runs there (and I mean absolutely no disrespect to small tired rigs) is the driveway to the sick stuff.

Here is a thread from last summer's BBQ. Most of it wasn't even the buggy trails. Brian and I both came away with borken stuff. They don't call him "Captain Carnage" for nothing :lol:

http://forum.baystatejeepers.com/viewto ... ?f=7&t=774



At the same area, here is the entrance to "Easy Street" :D
Image
Carl McFly wrote:X2, I agree with Joe. And not just because he's man candy
BSJ President 2003 - 2005
User avatar
ZAEDOCK
BSJ Member
Posts: 2428
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:18 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ZAEDOCK »

Brian!!!!!!!

BUY THIS! It's a freak'n awesome deal! If I had the cash, it would already be in my buggy.

http://forum.neow.net/index.php?showtopic=87227&st=0
Carl McFly wrote:X2, I agree with Joe. And not just because he's man candy
BSJ President 2003 - 2005
Captian Carnage
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 344
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 1:08 pm
Jeep Year: 2004
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by Captian Carnage »

That link that Joe put up with my rear tires in the air was after it came down LOL And the stock shaft lasted there with the weight of the jeep on 1 wheel that the fun stuff

Joe Im broke till febuary My truck and stuff cost me a total of 8 g in November LOL
nostaw

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by nostaw »

Captian Carnage wrote:That link that Joe put up with my rear tires in the air was after it came down LOL And the stock shaft lasted there with the weight of the jeep on 1 wheel that the fun stuff

Joe Im broke till febuary My truck and stuff cost me a total of 8 g in November LOL
Doesn't matter... Axle was sold this AM.

It is doing a great job holding a dolly down on my garage floor, for now... 8-)

JW
User avatar
ZAEDOCK
BSJ Member
Posts: 2428
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:18 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ZAEDOCK »

I'll take the 10% commission Jon...
Carl McFly wrote:X2, I agree with Joe. And not just because he's man candy
BSJ President 2003 - 2005
nostaw

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by nostaw »

ZAEDOCK wrote:I'll take the 10% commission Jon...
I'll buy you lunch at the next event (GAJR?) I see you at...

JW
User avatar
ZAEDOCK
BSJ Member
Posts: 2428
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:18 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by ZAEDOCK »

nostaw wrote:
ZAEDOCK wrote:I'll take the 10% commission Jon...
I'll buy you lunch at the next event (GAJR?) I see you at...

JW
Nah. I'll just take one night out with your girl :twisted: (...the XJ silly...).
Carl McFly wrote:X2, I agree with Joe. And not just because he's man candy
BSJ President 2003 - 2005
nostaw

Re: 8.8 + tire size

Unread post by nostaw »

ZAEDOCK wrote:Nah. I'll just take one night out with your girl :twisted: (...the XJ silly...).
She don't do that on a first date... :p

JW
Post Reply