Mitchell Differential

User avatar
Baseshakers
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 929
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:19 pm
Jeep Year: 2005
Jeep Model: LJ Wrangler

Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Baseshakers »

As many of you know I purchased a front axle from Mitchell Differential a few years back. I had tons of issues with them; weeks late, bad axle shafts, etc. Add one more to the list. The front truss broke off one end... It was barely welded at all! No penetration on the welds. Unbelievably poor workmanship, just one more reason not to go there. ImageImage
"god had his sh!t together when he made boobies" -franky
User avatar
Kurt
BSJ Member
Posts: 4203
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2009 11:53 am
Jeep Year: 1992
Jeep Model: YJ Wrangler
Real Name: Kurt K.
Location: Pepperell, MA

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Kurt »

Wow... :-o
"Build It, Run It, Break It, Improve It, Repeat!"
NEA Treasurer 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
BSJ Treasurer 2020
User avatar
Frank
Frankie BSJ Member
Posts: 4145
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2009 8:54 am
Jeep Year: 1974
Jeep Model: CJ5

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Frank »

Dude : You should be a Fireman , The way you get Hosed ! Thats bad Dude. I had the boys look at your picture and they said the same thing. No penetration and or two passes and they had porosity in between ! FjR68
User avatar
del_TJ
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 381
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 1:19 pm
Jeep Year: 1998
Jeep Model: TJ Wrangler
Location: Newton, MA

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by del_TJ »

Damn. That's on top of the previous problems you had... let me know if you need a wrenchfest day.
User avatar
Hoodoo Man
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 3799
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:29 am
Jeep Year: 1970
Jeep Model: C101
Real Name: Jeff Cambray
Location: Westford MA

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Hoodoo Man »

honestly I couldn't be less pleased with a vendor than these guys. I had a crap ton of debris in my rear diff fluid after they did my R&P. It was just scary. I have no idea what caused it as it seems to be fine now and thankfully it didn't destroy by ARB locker. they tossed my lube lockers in the trash and when I bitched about it they said they would send them to me, never did. I'm not impressed with this place at all. :(
1970 Jeepster- stock
2003 Jeep Rubicon 2" BDS Spring lift 35s and MCE fenders
2012 Jeep JKU 2.5' Terafkex spring lift, Rock Hard Bumpa, skids, BodyArmor4x4 sliders..
User avatar
Frank
Frankie BSJ Member
Posts: 4145
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2009 8:54 am
Jeep Year: 1974
Jeep Model: CJ5

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Frank »

I think they also did Fishs 9" rear that blew up the first day he wheeled it ! FjR68
User avatar
Baseshakers
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 929
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:19 pm
Jeep Year: 2005
Jeep Model: LJ Wrangler

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Baseshakers »

Yep franky, I got hosed. Well it's all welded back together now, with my 240V at peak power so it better hold! Not the prettiest welds in the world given the gap I had to deal with but a lot better than what was there.

Glad your ARB survived Jeff, I wouldn't be surprised if they screwed up the pattern initially. I remember the day Fish broke at F&F, he wasn't even romping on it! Unbelievable all around.
"god had his sh!t together when he made boobies" -franky
User avatar
Hoodoo Man
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 3799
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:29 am
Jeep Year: 1970
Jeep Model: C101
Real Name: Jeff Cambray
Location: Westford MA

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Hoodoo Man »

Baseshakers wrote:Yep franky, I got hosed. Well it's all welded back together now, with my 240V at peak power so it better hold! Not the prettiest welds in the world given the gap I had to deal with but a lot better than what was there.

Glad your ARB survived Jeff, I wouldn't be surprised if they screwed up the pattern initially. I remember the day Fish broke at F&F, he wasn't even romping on it! Unbelievable all around.
I guess we are just the outliers in the process, that are too rough with our stuff. :roll: :doh: Or they suck... :?
1970 Jeepster- stock
2003 Jeep Rubicon 2" BDS Spring lift 35s and MCE fenders
2012 Jeep JKU 2.5' Terafkex spring lift, Rock Hard Bumpa, skids, BodyArmor4x4 sliders..
84cj
BSJ Member
Posts: 378
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 1:03 pm
Jeep Year: 1984
Jeep Model: CJ7
Real Name: Curtis

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by 84cj »

Sorry for your bad experiences guys. But on the flip side, I had my rear axle tubes replaced (after a punishing trip to Rausch Creek a few years back) from Mitchell and I have had zero issues with it so far. Wait, maybe that is why I started flopping every other run. :lol:

I have no affiliation with the guys over there.

Curtis
Posimoto
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:36 pm
Jeep Year: 1954
Jeep Model: CJ3B

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Posimoto »

I'm curious if you talked to them and presented pics, if so what was their response?
User avatar
Frank
Frankie BSJ Member
Posts: 4145
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2009 8:54 am
Jeep Year: 1974
Jeep Model: CJ5

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Frank »

Dude : There is no excuse for that bridge to rip off the housing ! I welded Ryans Jeep back together in Rausch with a welder that was so bad Dennis had to twist the amp knob for it to put out enough to weld the control arms back on to drive it home. It was a bad weld from the begining. Poor prep, wrong heat setting, porosity between the beads. Some thing a professional Co. shouldnt have an issue with. Its what they do. Jeff had the same thing happen at F&F ,The bridge ripped off and cost him a driveshaft at the same time. Fish was doing a rock a stock JK might have made and a brand new R&P blew up. To many issues with them. FjR68
Posimoto
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:36 pm
Jeep Year: 1954
Jeep Model: CJ3B

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Posimoto »

I'm thinking your not addressing my post because nothing you posted has anything to do with my question, but I figured I'd ask because I wasn't sure.
User avatar
Baseshakers
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 929
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:19 pm
Jeep Year: 2005
Jeep Model: LJ Wrangler

Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Baseshakers »

Hey Posimoto, sorry, I wasn't trying to avoid answering your question. I haven't approached Mitchell with this latest issue as it has been a few years since they built the axle. I wouldn't expect any vendor to take care of a customer after this long (though some will go out of their way to do so). Honestly I could barely get Mitchell to call me back when they were smack in the middle of my build, so anything I send them now, many years later, will most likely go nowhere. Hell, when they screwed up my axle shafts they still charged me to fix them! I just welded the damn truss back on myself and called it a day.
"god had his sh!t together when he made boobies" -franky
User avatar
Hoodoo Man
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 3799
Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 11:29 am
Jeep Year: 1970
Jeep Model: C101
Real Name: Jeff Cambray
Location: Westford MA

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Hoodoo Man »

Posimoto wrote:I'm curious if you talked to them and presented pics, if so what was their response?

he accused me of not breaking the R&P in properly. _ I did stopping several times for cool down on the drive home and it was fouled diff fluid due to off road use. there were a chit load of metal flakes that were either from before the swap or a bad setup. Its working OK several years later but he does not stand behind the work he just did and never was able to send me a pattern which I requested. the slap em together and call it good without documenting much. Im sure they would either a) remember Ryan and say look at the abuse to your Jeep or b) outright ignore him. #vendorFail
1970 Jeepster- stock
2003 Jeep Rubicon 2" BDS Spring lift 35s and MCE fenders
2012 Jeep JKU 2.5' Terafkex spring lift, Rock Hard Bumpa, skids, BodyArmor4x4 sliders..
Posimoto
BSJ 101 Planning Commitee
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:36 pm
Jeep Year: 1954
Jeep Model: CJ3B

Re: Mitchell Differential

Unread post by Posimoto »

Baseshakers wrote:Hey Posimoto, sorry, I wasn't trying to avoid answering your question. I haven't approached Mitchell with this latest issue as it has been a few years since they built the axle. I wouldn't expect any vendor to take care of a customer after this long (though some will go out of their way to do so). Honestly I could barely get Mitchell to call me back when they were smack in the middle of my build, so anything I send them now, many years later, will most likely go nowhere. Hell, when they screwed up my axle shafts they still charged me to fix them! I just welded the damn truss back on myself and called it a day.
Thanks for the reply. I asked because I cut down my front 44 a few years ago and had them cut and respline the axle shaft and all was good. However, last year when I cut down my front 60 I sent them my axle shaft to be shorten and respline, this time it wasn't cut to my specs. I called the owner and he said he cut it personally and was sure it was cut correctly. I told him he was mistaken and the shaft was too long. He did say he was would re-cut the shaft and or send me a u-joint for the trouble. I simply cut down the shaft to my specs and tapered back the splines.

I would recommend contacting the owner and speak only to him. He should know what type of work is coming out of his shop and have a chance to make it good with you, this type of work has no time limit.
Post Reply